Atria Bay Shore
$5,995 – $9,695/mo
Starting price
Memory Care
Care types
Studio, 1 Bedroom, 2 Bedroom
Room options
Yes
Wheelchair access
About Atria Bay Shore
Atria Bay Shore is distinguished by its elegant setting in a beautifully restored 19th-century mansion along Long Island’s scenic waterfront. The community blends historic charm with modern comforts, including spacious private suites and canal views. Residents benefit from a comprehensive care spectrum, from independent living to specialized memory care with 24-hour support. The Engage Life® program enriches daily life with diverse activities, wellness options, and social events. On-site amenities like a fitness center, salon, library, and multiple dining venues support an active, fulfilling lifestyle. Its location near parks, cafes, and local shops offers both tranquility and convenience for residents and their families.
Our Care Approach
Atria Bay Shore emphasizes personalized, discreet care tailored to each resident’s needs. The community supports independence while providing up to 16 hours of daily nursing and specialized memory care. Staff turnover is low, reflecting a stable team focused on respectful, attentive service.
Family Experience
Families often describe positive visits marked by friendly communication and visible resident happiness. Many appreciate the staff’s dedication and the community’s openness to family involvement. Some concerns have been raised about staff responsiveness, but overall family satisfaction is high.
Care & Services
Services and care programs available at Atria Bay Shore.
Medical Care Services
Includes 24-hour supervision, nursing care up to 16 hours daily, medication management, insulin administration, and coordination with local healthcare providers.
Personal Care Services
Assistance with daily living activities such as bathing, dressing, medication reminders, and mobility support provided by dedicated on-site caregivers.
Specialized Care
Secure memory care neighborhood with 24-hour staff support tailored for residents with Alzheimer’s and other dementias through the Life Guidance® program.
Interested in learning more about the care options?
Living Environment
Cleanliness & Maintenance
Most reviews commend the community’s cleanliness and well-maintained historic building, though isolated reports mention pest issues and lapses in hygiene.
Atmosphere & Community Feel
Atria Bay Shore fosters a welcoming, family-like atmosphere with active social programming and resident engagement, supported by friendly and polite staff.
Safety & Security
The community provides 24-hour supervision, emergency alert systems, and a secure memory care neighborhood, ensuring resident safety and peace of mind.
Amenities
Reviews
Based on 36 reviews
Reviews reflect a generally positive experience with many praising the friendly, attentive staff and clean, welcoming environment. Several families highlight the quality of memory care and the supportive atmosphere. However, a few negative reviews raise concerns about staff attentiveness and cleanliness issues, indicating some variability in experiences. Overall, the community is viewed as a solid choice for assisted living and memory care with a strong team and engaging activities.
- Dedicated and friendly staff
- Clean and inviting atmosphere
- Good memory care with low staff turnover
- Concerns about staff being inattentive and distracted
- Reported cleanliness issues including pests
- Negative experiences with Life Guidance residents' care
Brenda Rink
A lovely and welcoming community. Although I have my husband at another place, Atria was not close enough to my home. Dedicated and friendly staff.
saleena veliz
This place is one of the worst places that i have seen, the staff are treated terribly and everyone is on there phones. As well as nobody cares for the Life Guidance Residents instead they ignore and give dirty looks when they are in need of help. There are worms in the coffee as well which shows how dirty this place really is. If you are looking for care i recommend somewhere else.
Michelle Amerson
Wonderful place to be
11 more residents rated this community with an average of 4.4 stars
Families love this community. See if it’s the right fit for you.
Pricing
$5,995 – $9,695/mo
Pricing varies by room type, care level, and services selected.
Available Room Types
Value Consideration
With monthly costs ranging from $5,995 to $9,695, Atria Bay Shore offers a broad range of care levels and amenities that justify the pricing. The inclusion of wellness programs, diverse dining options, and comprehensive care services supports a strong value proposition for families seeking quality assisted living and memory care.
Location & Neighborhood
53 Ocean Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Get DirectionsAbout the Area
Located in Bay Shore, New York, Atria Bay Shore sits near the picturesque Great South Bay, offering a peaceful waterfront setting with easy access to local shops, dining, and parks. The community benefits from a blend of small-town charm and proximity to metropolitan amenities, creating a balanced environment for seniors.
Nearby Attractions
- Benjamin’s Memorial Beach
- Seatuck National Wildlife Refuge
- Westfield South Shore shopping center
Public Transportation
- Scheduled transportation service provided by the community
- Local public transit options connecting to Bay Shore area
Questions & Answers
Community Updates
Latest News
2025-09-29T18:45:40.000Z
Join us on Thursday, October 9 and bring well-loved books and discover new ones at our book swap and author talk.
2025-09-04T17:53:07.000Z
Join us on Thursday, September 18 and roll the dice in great company to win prizes! If you’re betting on fun, you’ll hit the jackpot at our casino-themed party.
2025-08-06T15:05:51.000Z
Join us on Thursday, August 14 to enjoy camping-style treats and encounter wildlife as we celebrate the majesty of the great outdoors.
2025-06-30T18:06:39.000Z
Who will reign supreme when our chef takes on a resident’s cherished family recipe? It’s sure to be a flavorful feud over one family’s food. Join us for the Chef Showdown on Thursday, July 10th.
2025-05-29T14:17:01.000Z
Bring your pets – or just come hang with ours – as we celebrate our animal friends and help collect donations for local shelters at our Whiskers & Wags event on Thursday, June 12. Participate in our pet costume contest for a chance to win a prize.
2025-05-08T16:31:14.000Z
Join us on Thursday, May 22, for our Majesty of Asia event as we explore the beauty and diversity of Asia, from its history and culture to cuisine and traditions.
Ready to learn more about Atria Bay Shore?
Get your free personalized path or schedule a visit today.